Best Colors to Paint Your Exterior in Bay Shore

Top Exterior Paint Trends in the Bay Shore Area

At CertaPro Painters® of Bay Shore, NY, we know that a fresh coat of exterior paint is one of the most powerful ways to boost your home’s curb appeal—especially here in Suffolk County, where coastal weather and neighborhood styles play a big role in choosing the right colors. Whether you’re updating a classic Cape, a traditional Colonial, or a waterfront property, we’re breaking down the top exterior paint color trends in Bay Shore. From timeless neutrals to deep, dramatic tones, we’ll guide you through what’s trending locally—and how to choose colors that work with your home’s materials, surroundings, and architectural style.

1. Clean Whites & Soft Creams

Crisp, welcoming whites like Alabaster or Greek Villa continue to be a favorite across Long Island. At CertaPro Painters of Bay Shore, NY, we often recommend pairing them with dark trim—think black or navy—for a high-contrast, upscale look that suits both traditional and modern homes.

2. Bold Charcoal & Matte Black

For homeowners looking to make a statement, rich dark colors like Tricorn Black or Iron Ore are rising in popularity. These shades bring depth and sophistication—perfect for modern farmhouse styles or updated colonials found in the Bay Shore area.

3. Coastal-Inspired Blues & Grays

Soft grays, pale blues, and misty sea-glass hues reflect the coastal character of Bay Shore. Colors like Rainwashed, Evening Shadow, or Storm Cloud are perfect for homes near the water or with light stonework or siding.

4. Earthy Neutrals

Warm taupes, beiges, and muted greens like Dried Thyme or Accessible Beige offer a natural, grounded look. These colors complement brick exteriors, stone details, and lush landscaping often found throughout Bay Shore and the surrounding Suffolk County neighborhoods.

🏡 What This Means for Your Bay Shore Home

At CertaPro Painters® of Bay Shore, NY, here’s what we’re seeing most often:

• White exteriors with dark or navy trim for a sharp, classic finish

• Nature-inspired neutrals that blend beautifully with Long Island’s environment

• Statement dark colors used on full exteriors, doors, or shutters

• Soft blue-greens and grays that bring a calm, coastal feel

Not sure what will look best on your home? Tools like the CertaPro Visualizer or Sherwin-Williams ColorSnap® make it easy to preview colors before you paint.

Final Tips

Choose a versatile base color first—then build your trim and accent colors for balance and contrast.

If you’re thinking long-term (like resale value), stick to classic neutrals or warm whites.

Want a pop? Use a bold front door or colorful shutters to make a statement without committing to a full-color overhaul.

Ready to give your home a fresh new look? Schedule a FREE estimate today with CertaPro Painters® of Bay Shore, NY